
A bakery can keep customers seated and its display stock intact by customising the Guest role. Check the permissions on the role your customers actually receive.
Review the display and counter separately
On the in-game phone, open My Plot, Permissions and the permission settings. For Guest, switch off taking items from displays. If you serve food on an open counter too, check the separate controls for picking up items and taking portions. A cake sitting on the counter is a different test from one inside the case.
Source: Developer FAQ for Welcome to Bloxburg, Bakery owners discuss display permissions
Test with an inexpensive dish
Put an ordinary dish in the display and invite a friend with Guest permissions. Have them try the case and then a chair. Hand customers a tray yourself if you have disabled self-service. Review refrigerator access in the same menu before stocking limited seasonal dishes.
Source: Developer FAQ for Welcome to Bloxburg, Bakery owners discuss display permissions
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.