
Equip Reverse and have a partner bring Bubble. You want their ability projectile to touch you while your reflection is active. Trading regular slaps does not create the projectile the badge checks.
Leave room for the shot
Face one another outside normal slapping range. Ask the Bubble user to send a bubble straight towards you. A little space makes it easier to see where it is headed and time your effect, particularly when you are practising with a friend.
Source: Player demonstration of the Potato unlock, Bubble reflection walkthrough
Check who earned the badge
Move into the path with Reverse active. The player reflecting the shot earns Sorry to burst your bubble. If both of you want potato, swap gloves after the first notification and let the other player reflect the next shot. Equip your new glove back in the lobby.
Source: Player demonstration of the Potato unlock, Bubble reflection walkthrough
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.