
To try another stroke, stop in the water and start swimming again. The game picks one of three strokes at random each time. There is no button for choosing a specific stroke.
When to stop and start again
Swim into a forest pond and watch the character’s arms. Release the movement control and wait until you stop travelling forward. Stay still for at least a fifth of a second, then move again. For a first attempt, a full second makes the pause easy to judge.
If the arms do the same thing again, try another stop. The same stroke can come up twice in a row. Turning while you keep swimming does not trigger a fresh choice.
Source: Open World: getting started
How to tell the three strokes apart
In front crawl, the arms alternate and the torso rolls from side to side. In breaststroke, both arms reach forward, sweep outward and return towards the chest. In butterfly, both arms circle together and the body rises and dips in a wave.
Source: Open World: getting started
Does butterfly take you underwater?
The dip during butterfly is part of the stroke. You stay at the surface, and switching strokes cannot trigger a dive. Try crossing the middle of the pond twice in the same gear. Without a swimming bonus from armour, you move at 55% of your land speed in the deep part, whichever stroke you draw. The slowdown eases near the bank.
Source: Open World: getting started
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.