
Open the pause menu and go to Stats → Awards → The Doomsday Heist. Criminal Mastermind has three separate entries here. The Roman numeral is the total crew size, including the host.
Pick the same row across all three acts
A duo follows Criminal Mastermind II from the first mission through the Act III finale. Three players track III and four track IV. Starting a new act leaves that choice unchanged. Run the missions in order, keep the same teammates throughout and select Hard when setting up jobs with a difficulty option.
Source: Rockstar Games — Doomsday Heist completion awards, GTA Series Videos — three-act gameplay guide
Compare each player’s own counter
After a job, have everyone open the matching award and read out their own progress. The facility board tells you which mission opens next, while each player’s Stats menu shows their award. If one counter has reset, check the crew, mission order, difficulty and whether anyone died during a setup or finale before continuing.
Source: Rockstar Games — Doomsday Heist completion awards, GTA Series Videos — three-act gameplay guide
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.