
The teacher remembers a returned Water Key. If he thanked you and told you to come back, you can stop fighting the Tide Keeper for another drop. Check the remaining purchase requirements before you visit again.
Deliver the key on Forgotten Island
Fight the Tide Keeper at the back of Forgotten Island in the Second Sea. When the Water Key drops, take it straight to the Sharkman Teacher outside a house on the island. A death or disconnect before the hand-in costs you the key. Older guides call this teacher Daigrock.
Source: Water Key, Sharkman Teacher
Check the mastery on Water Kung Fu
Equip Water Kung Fu and read its mastery counter. You need 400 mastery in that style regardless of your character level or Melee stat. Bring 2,500,000 Beli and 5,000 Fragments, speak to the teacher again and accept the purchase. Your fighting style panel should now show Sharkman Karate.
Source: Water Key, Sharkman Teacher
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.