
The Roman numeral counts how many times a player has reached level 100 and chosen Prestige. You have to accept the first reset yourself to earn I. Playing another regular round at 100 does not award the numeral automatically.
When to select Prestige
Reach level 100 and look for Prestige in the interface. Accept the prompt when you are ready to start another run through the levels. You can leave the control alone if you want to keep the plain 100 beside your name for now.
Source: MM2 Wiki · Prestige, Player question about the Roman numeral
How to read I 1 or I 24
After your first reset, the regular counter starts at one and I appears beside it. Someone marked I 24 has already completed one cycle and reached level 24 in the next. Read both parts when comparing two players with the same number on the right.
Source: MM2 Wiki · Prestige, Player question about the Roman numeral
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.