
Fishing is catch and release. TGG asked about the catch at the GTA VI preview and reported Rob Nelson’s answer: you cannot take the fish away with you.
Where fishing appears in the showcase
Skip to about 25:50 in An Extended Look, during the closing sequence on the water. The fishing scene introduces the pastime. It cuts away without a results screen listing a price, a catch weight or an option to keep the fish.
Why the Red Dead comparison only goes so far
TGG compared the depth of the activity to Red Dead Redemption 2 and separately recorded Nelson’s explanation about keeping fish. That distinction matters if you are planning ahead: a catch does not give you a fish to carry off for sale or supper.
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.