
Save your first Bunny Foot for the trader. A Bear Pelt is valuable, but he only asks for it after you finish the first three exchanges.
Prepare for the Day 2 visit
Hunt bunnies on the first day and check their drops for a foot. You may need several tries. When the trader arrives near camp on Day 2, hand him the foot and choose one reward. A Good Sack helps you bring more loot home per trip, while a Good Axe cuts down trees faster.
Source: Trade table and reward screen, The first trade at camp
Work through your own requests
After the foot, bring a regular Wolf Pelt, then an Alpha Wolf Pelt and finally a Bear Pelt. Each trade advances your own request. A teammate can still owe a foot while you are choosing a reward for a bear hide. Keep any later hides if the trader leaves and bring them to his next visit.
Source: Trade table and reward screen, The first trade at camp
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.