
Elemental checks for three different shields active at the same moment. Finding all three in one round does not count if the first wears off before you collect the last.
Which three effects count?
The three effects are Magic Shield, Fire Shield and Crystal Shield. A second pickup of one type cannot fill the missing slot. If you find several shields in a cave, identify the types first, then collect them close together.
Source: Official Elemental badge requirement, Mechanics and route
Hold the Magic Shield for last
One route uses Forcefield with Overcharge. Keep the Magic Shield available while looking for Fire Shield and Crystal Shield. Trigger it once both other effects are active, so the third shield does not depend on finding another pickup in time.
Source: Official Elemental badge requirement, Mechanics and route
Sources
Interfaces and rules can change. Check the official pages above for current requirements.